Scholarly Articles
Nick Swisher
Research and Writing in History
Prof. Julius
March 17, 2010
Research Report # 6: Scholarly Articles
Previously, I wrote of what I had learned from several primary sources and a book. These led me to find the answers to two of my research questions. One of these questions was to determine what impact the Civil War had upon West Virginia and vise versa. I may have answered this question in part, but I believe that I can dig deeper. With the help of two scholarly articles, I intend to further uncover the depth of depth of my question. It has become apparent that the Shenandoah Valley was perhaps the most vital part of West Virginia to the war effort, so I intend to come to a fuller understanding of what happened there.
I had learned that General Sheridan used his Union forces to march through the Shenandoah Valley and strip it bare of resources. However, through the research of these scholarly articles I learned that he was not the first to do so. Apparently there were several generals whom Grant had sent to effectively remove the Shenandoah Valley from the Confederates grasp, but Sheridan was the one who returned with an overwhelming success. Grant realized that the Shenandoah Valley was important for several reasons. The valley was a critical source of salt and lead to the Confederates as well as the most reliable source for food. Aside from that, the railroads that ran through the valley connected it with several key territories. This enabled the confederates to resupply their troops with the valleys resources, or to shift their forces along those lines quickly. Grant, who was himself too bust on the Eastern front, divided the Valley between three Generals. He commanded General Crook to break one of the major railroad lines; General Averell was told to destroy the salt and lead mines; and General Sigel would attempt to control some of the most direct railroad lines into Richmond, Virginia. [i]
These plans would ultimately fail, mostly due to inept command. Sheridan would later take over the operation and prove it’s decisiveness. Until then however, it was left in the hands of Crook, Averell and Sigel. As their separate campaigns marched onward, Sigel would soon be replaced by another, General Hunter. Crook and Averell would be placed under Hunter’s command. Hunter’s march through the Shenandoah Valley would become even more infamous than Sheridan’s who followed in its wake. Grant ordered Hunter to “Clear the Valley of all enemy forces and all means of supplying the Confederacy, then go after either Charlottesville or Lynchburg.”[ii] Hunter went on to inform his men that they would be living off of what food the valley provided. He was also confronted with the issue of guerrilla warfare. The amount of Confederate soldiers spread throughout the valley was small, so many resorted to sporadic hit and run attacks. Hunter dealt with these in a harsh manner; for every attack made upon his army he would destroy the private property of those living in the valley. Throughout his entire march through the valley his men were burning down houses. The initial idea had been to burn any factories or warehouses that had, or could possibly, aid the Confederates. However, Hunter soon demanded that the houses of Confederate sympathizers be burnt as well. [iii]
As the army marched on, and food supplies grew short, pillaging became a major issue. Hunter seemed willing to allow this, however several of his subordinates would disagree. Men like Averell and Crook would delay Hunter’s orders or attempt to convince him otherwise when he sought to burn down innocent’s houses. Despite their attempts at civility, the Union army would often leave naught more than ash in its wake. Several stories stand out among those of Hunters march, among them are the tales of disobedience from Hunter’s officers who refused to commit heinous acts. For me, however, one of the most interesting stories is that among those officers who defied Hunter was one would-be president of the United States, Rutherford B. Hayes. [iv]
In the end, Hunter’s incompetence as a leader would become apparent. He marched his forces up to Lynchburg but was met by a small garrison of men led by General Early of the Confederate forces. Hunter was bluffed into believing that the Confederate forces were larger in number than they truly were and he ended up retreating. This led Early to retaliate and march back up the Shenandoah Valley into Maryland which is where Sheridan then repulsed him. All in all, I believe I have learned a great deal more about what the Shenandoah Valley meant to both sides of the war, and even to its inhabitants. Next time, I hope to learn even more about West Virginia in the Civil war with the aid of some books.[v]
[i] Ralph Mann, review of Lee’s Endangered Left: The Civil War in Western
Virginia, Spring of 1864, by Richard R. Duncan, The Journal of American History
87 (June 2000): https://ezproxy.stevenson.edu:1443/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=ahl&AN=A000482627.01&site=ehost-live (accessed March
17, 2010).
[ii] L. VanLoan Naisawald, “Fire and Ashes in the Valley,” Civil War Times
45 (2006): https://ezproxy.stevenson.edu:1443/login?url=http://search.ebscohost.com/
login.aspx?direct=true&db=ahl&AN=A800003302.01&site=ehost-live (accessed March
17, 2010).
[iii] IBID
[iv] IBID
[v] IBID